Memo to ‘best of’ listmakers: Narratives with powerful female protagonists are FOR EVERYONE

When Cate Blanchett accepted her Oscar a couple weeks ago, she told the world that movies with women at the center are not a niche market, that those movies make money. I couldn’t agree more. And it’s not just my opinion, or Blanchett’s, of course. “Catching Fire” starring Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen is the highest grossing movie of 2013 while “Frozen,” starring sisters Elsa and Anna, just crossed the billion dollar mark in worldwide ticket sales.

So why do we still think of women and girls, one half of the human population, like some kind of special interest group? As the mom of three young daughters, I am particularly frustrated by how this gender myth– that boys won’t engage in media about female protagonists– is perpetuated in kidworld, where stores like Target or Toys R Us divide merchandise into generalized and stereotyped boy/ girl aisles and On Demand categorizes TV shows starring girls into a separate group.

There’s another place we really need to stop segregating kids and that’s in the girl empowerment community. There are so many great “best of” lists that go around the internet featuring media with strong girls, but too often, there’s a persistent preposition problem: books about girls are promoted as for girls. Books about girls are for everyone.

GirlPowerReadingList

New York Public Library’s site just put out a great list featuring books like Inside Out and Back Again by Thanhha Lai, The Skin I’m In by Sharon Flake, and Breath, Eyes, Memory by Edwidge Danticat, among others. Typically, this is how the list is headed:

Girl Power: Books for Bold Women.

 

The listmaker goes on to introduce her amazing books with this qualifier:

Smart, strong women deserve books filled with smart, strong female characters. Luckily, there are many books with protagonists who speak out for justice, make courageous choices, and know that womanhood is beautiful. That’s why we’ve compiled a list of recommendations for the woman who expects her fiction to be as bold as she is. From Haitian short fiction to literature of the southern immigrant experience, these books will make you believe in girl power.

 

Smart, strong people deserve books filled with smart, strong female characters.

If I didn’t see this happen so many times, I wouldn’t blog about it, but here’s the thing: I’m grateful dedicated people are making these lists, but as long as we keep segregating the fiction world, we’ll segregate the real one. Please, keep an eye out for how often you see media about women and girls marketed as for women and girls. If you’re a parent, please seek out books, movies, games, and apps featuring powerful female protagonists for your sons as well as your daughters.

Update: Please sign the petition from Let Toys Be Toys For Girls and Boys asking publishers of children’s books to stop marketing to books to girls or boys.

 

Titles like “The Beautiful Girls’ Book of Colouring” or “Illustrated Classics for Boys” send the message that certain books are off-limits for girls or for boys, and promote limiting gender stereotypes.

 

How can a story or a colouring page be only for a girl or only for a boy? A good book should be open to anyone, and children should feel free to choose books that interest them. It’s time to Let Books Be Books.

 

9 thoughts on “Memo to ‘best of’ listmakers: Narratives with powerful female protagonists are FOR EVERYONE

  1. I’m raising a white son, and I think he may need books about strong girls and women, people of color, people with disabilities, and other diversity almost as much as anyone else. How else is he going to learn that his experience and privilege are not universal, and to be the guy who’s fighting to dismantle privilege?

  2. We need to find a different way to phrase “strong female characters” because that apparently implies to the entertainment world that we want “characters: strong female”…so they make action movies and such that feature female-shaped characters kicking butt and swaggering around without any of those weaknesses like feelings. What we SHOULD somehow express is that when we say we want “strong female characters” what we mean is that we want “strong characters: female”…..Meaning, strongly WRITTEN female characters. Characters with realistic feelings, thoughts, motives, and flaws….characters that aren’t just caricatures. A character doesn’t have to be physically strong to be a “strong character”.

  3. Thanks to your blog, I’ve been noticing how many shows and books my boys enjoy that star girls and women. It really is a perception and marketing problem only. It simply isn’t true that boys wont read or watch stories about girls.

  4. Thanks to your blog, I’ve been noticing how many shows and books my boys enjoy that star girls and women. It really is the marketing that’s the problem. It simply isn’t true that boys wont read or watch stories about girls.

  5. As a librarian I couldn’t agree more.You wouldn’t believe, (well, I guess you would) the number of “Awesome Books for Girls” lists out there.And your advice applies to more than parents: uncles, aunts, grandparents, friends of the family, teachers: give boys books about girls and women!

Leave a Reply